Combined BA/MD Degree Program
Portfolio Requirement
BA/MD Portfolio Student Guidelines
Overview. Each semester when you take a BA/MD seminar or
participate in the summer practicum, the BA/MD Academic
Advisor will collect a portfolio containing a twelve- to fifteen-page sample
of your best written work from the course, and, if necessary, from one or
more of your other courses for which you submitted written work during the
semester.
The portfolio provides an
ongoing record of your progress in writing on a variety of topics and in a
variety of genres. The Curriculum Committee will use the portfolio to
evaluate the longitudinal effectiveness of the writing components in the
HMHV curriculum, and your Physician Mentor will use the portfolio to
encourage you to think reflectively about your accomplishments during the
semester and to discuss your personal progress.
What is the
portfolio? A portfolio is a twelve- to
fifteen-page collection of your work representing what you believe to be
your best writing of the semester. The portfolio must include at least one
representative sample of your writing for the HMHV program—short essays,
term papers, research papers, personal essays, memoirs, examination essays,
lab reports, and/or creative writing. The semester in which you take the
HMHV: 201 Seminar: Literature, Fine Arts & Medicine, you should submit your
personal essay and preface, when required, or your longer paper, when
required, for the Portfolio. In other semesters, the writing sample may be
in the form of one longer paper, or a combination of three or four papers of
no fewer than 750 words each. At least one writing sample should come from
the seminar or practicum.
Each portfolio must include
a three- to five-page (750- to 1250-word) preface or cover letter reflecting
on the work you have done and the academic and personal gains you have made
during the semester. The preface or cover letter should discuss briefly what
you were trying to achieve in the written works assembled in the preface,
should consider how well you think you accomplished your learning objectives
for the semester, and reflect upon how you have developed as a writer and
student so far. (See the Guidelines for Composition and Evaluation for more
details.) Thus, the preface or cover letter should present a synopsis or
profile of your growth as a student in general, as well as discuss your
writing in particular.
Papers in the portfolio
should be at least three double-spaced pages long (750 words), and the
portfolio should contain a total of twelve to fifteen pages of your writing.
You may revise the portfolio papers before submitting them, though you need
not do so (see “Preparing the Portfolio” below).
Preparing the portfolio. Submit the portfolio both in hard copy and
electronically (via e-mail as a pdf file) at the end of the semester to the
BA/MD Academic Advisor. Follow these guidelines for submitting papers:
- Proofread and correct any typing, spelling, or grammatical errors.
- Ensure each paper included in the portfolio is at least 750 words (three double-spaced pages,
twelve-point font) and that each paper is numbered (page numbers).
- Ensure the portfolio contains at least twelve to fifteen pages of writing.
- Include a description of the assignment for which each paper was written.
- Include the date of completion and date of revision for each paper.
- Include a three- to five-page preface or cover letter discussing briefly what you were trying to
achieve as a writer of the work you include in your paper, as well as some
general reflection on how well you think you have accomplished your overall
learning objectives for the semester.
- Ensure there are no instructor’s marks or comments on the papers.
Submitting the portfolio. Turn in a hard copy of the portfolio in a
manila envelope addressed to the BA/MD Academic Advisor and e-mail to the
advisor as a pdf or rtf attachment (Pdf files ensure that your work cannot be
modified.) Please copy your Physician Mentor, so that he or she will be able to
read your portfolio and discuss it with you. Assemble the preface and writing
sample(s) in one electronic file with your name and “portfolio” in the subject
line. Be sure that both the hard copy and electronic copy of the portfolio meet
the criteria indicated in “Preparing the portfolio” (above).
The Preface/Cover Letter. As an example of reflective writing in which
you discuss your learning experience in general and your writing in particular,
the preface or cover letter is an essential component of the portfolio. The
preface or cover letter gives you the opportunity to assess your own work in
terms of meeting the objectives you set out to achieve for the writing
assignment, your sense of progress or improvement from draft to final version,
and your growth as a writer. In addition, and importantly, the preface or cover
letter allows you to think about your overall learning objectives for the
semester and to consider how well you have grown as a student and person. The
cover letter answers such questions as: What did I learn about myself as a
student, person, and writer this semester? What were my learning objectives and
to what degree did I achieve them? What did I do well in the papers assembled
for the preface? How did my writing improve and how did my writing help me to
improve as a student, if it did? The cover letter should be at least 750 words
(three double-spaced pages).
Each reflective preface or cover letter should address the following outcomes or points:
- Individual learning objectives and outcomes
- Growth and development as a student, researcher, writer, and thinker
The preface also should address at least three of the following in relation to
the writing you have assembled for your portfolio:
- Process of Composition and Revision
- Overall Organization and Unity
- Purpose, Thesis, and Problem Articulation
- Rhetorical context
- Awareness of basic elements of craft and composition
What are the goals of the BA/MD program for the development of my writing skills?
Because writing involves a variety of skills and competencies, from basic grammar to critical
and analytical thinking, improvement in writing
is a crucial component of the BA/MD program’s curricular goals. Over the
undergraduate portion of the program, BA/MD students should demonstrate
increasing proficiency in the following:
- Complex critical and analytical thinking.
- Ability to analyze, interpret, and evaluate primary texts, personal and
clinical experiences, and social-scientific data.
- Ability to analyze and interpret literature about illness, health, and medicine.
- Ability to articulate and demonstrate the value of literature as a form of
personal expression through reflective writing.
- Ability to recognize and use effectively advanced writing skills, including
thesis development, style, syntax, diction, grammar, spelling, punctuation,
and documentation.
- Ability to conduct research, interpret data, and present in written and/or
verbal form the research results.
What should I concentrate on when revising my essays for inclusion in the portfolio?
The following guidelines apply primarily to academic writing, but as a general rule of thumb are
characteristics found in all good writing. When you revise and proofread your
essays keep in mind these points:
- The essay should present a strong, complex thesis that expresses your
particular stance on an arguable issue.
- The essay should support the thesis with pertinent evidence in the
form of concrete examples, details, and brief quotations from the primary
texts and from any secondary sources you might use.
- Sound reasoning and good organization is essential to your
argument. Present subordinate ideas logically and consistently, so that they
are clearly linked (whether directly or indirectly) to the main idea, and
provide logical transitions between paragraphs. Begin with a strong
introduction that gives your reader a conceptual map of the essay and sets
up his or her expectations; end with a strong conclusion that sums up the
main points of the argument, resolves any questions left open in your
discussion, and establishes closure for your reader.
- Check for basic writing skills: Write clearly, use appropriate
diction, vary your sentence structure, and proofread your paper to correct
any mechanical, grammatical, syntactical, or spelling errors.
Rev. January 26th, 2008